Should you ask your Attorney to perform a prior art search prior to filing a regular patent application?
Upon asking several attorneys, it appears the answer is...
It depends.
Summary: An extensive prior art search undertaken prior to issuance of any patent in a patent family can increase the presumed validity of any patent of that family that cites said relevant prior art. All patents of a given family should cite all relevant prior art for the entire family prior to issuance. Early searching combined with crafting claims around such search results may significantly increase upfront search and attorney expense but a more precisely crafted claim set can maintain positive momentum through the patent office with an appropriately broad claim set.
However, an extensive prior art search in an operating company can expose the company to claims of willful infringement and triple damages. That can be mitigated by a freedom to operate letter, which are unreasonably complex and expensive for startups to consider. However, it can also be mitigated by a strong and valid offensive portfolio. Such a portfolio would be available for countersuit.
Professional Prior Art Searches:
* Using a third party searcher cost $1k-$2k
* Typically produce 24 references which can be culled by the attorney to 10 relevant references.
* Take as input a one or two paragraph summary of the invention, the heart of the invention, novel and important aspects. Search for patents which contain keywords of proposed independent claims. Search for patents with the assignee field equal to that of known competitors.
Reasons to perform a prior art search:
* Patent drafting and prosecution is a long and expensive process. Innovation and commercialization can be even longer and more expensive by one or two orders of magnitude. In the event of finding damaging prior art that would eliminate the potential to receive patent protection, it is better to avoid the expense and time of the filing of claims that will be invalidated or denied.
My opinion: Usually the go no-go decision will not rest on patentability of a particular claim, or in fact of any claims at all. However, raising external capital or doing an M&A deal is more challenging without a patent in place. Yet, a picture claim that issues in a patent may be sufficient for deals that are not IP-centric.
* Patent claim drafting can be focused to overcome known existing prior art.
* Patent claim drafting can be directed to non-obvious improvements to known prior art.
Reasons not to perform prior art search:
* No obligation on the inventor or their attorney to seek to discover prior art or to search prior art.
* An issued patent that is part of a patent family may be damaged by the discovery of prior art after the date of it's issuance. That prior art would be raised immediately in court as a challenge to the issued patent.
* Searching art and acknowledging it makes infringement thereof willful. Those triple damages can be mitigated by a freedom to operate legal opinion. However, the freedom to operate opinion is 100-200 pages of legal analysis.
* No need to search or disclose prior art in a provisional patent application or in a utility application. However, with a utility application an IDS would be filed citing prior art references.
How many references to cite?
* Once a patent issues, it is presumed valid over the cited references... with a 90% validity (clear and convincing) rather than a 50%+ (preponderance of evidence)...
* Usually submitting "too much" is better
* Examiner will initial references examined. Those are helpful in front of USPTO.
* Relevant references should be cited, even 100 or 1000. Anything that raises the issue of patentability.
* Irrelevant references can be viewed as an attempt to flood the system and discourage the examiner from evaluating them. Thus, it could weaken the standard of evidence later in court if fact finder perceives references were not relevant.
* Hundreds of relevant references are better.
Product Launch Journey
Applying Product Launch Formula from Jeff Walker to launch a membership based website for a mission-based organization. jQuery, Python, Django, Flash, ActionScript 3, are applied to software as a service educational website.
Tuesday, May 21, 2019
Thursday, May 7, 2015
Shoobx Beta Client Questionnaire (if you say that you are an entreprenuer, if say legal counsel, then no more questions)
Shoobx Beta Client Questionnaire |
New round of funding raises the investment to $120 million for 100,000 students
New round of funding raises the investment to $120 million
Open English receives $65 million investment
OpenEnglish, the online English school, has received new investments
of US$65 million The capital is being provided by Technology Crossover
Ventures Fund, and by Insight Venture Partners and Redpoint Ventures.
The latter two have invested in the company previously. The most recent
capital commitment brings total investment in the school, which has
about 100,000 students in Latin America, to US$120 million.Thank you for your proposal -- Leads
esljobs.com
teflcourse.net
craigslist.org
careerbuilder.com
esljobsfeed.com
eslcafe.com
monster.com
Native/conversational/fluent/no
teflcourse.net
craigslist.org
careerbuilder.com
esljobsfeed.com
eslcafe.com
monster.com
Native/conversational/fluent/no
Thank you for your proposal
Thank you for taking the time to consider this teaching opportunity and for completing the Teacher Proposal Form.
You will receive a confirmation email, sent to the address you have listed in this proposal. Please check your SPAM and other email filters and add @openenglish.com to your safe senders list to ensure that you are receiving all correspondence from our team.
Your proposal record will be stored in our system and reviewed as contract opportunities become available. You need not submit your proposal more than once. Should you receive an error message upon submission, please DO NOT resubmit or complete the proposal again. Your data will be saved despite the error, and we will contact you should we need any further information.
You will receive a confirmation email, sent to the address you have listed in this proposal. Please check your SPAM and other email filters and add @openenglish.com to your safe senders list to ensure that you are receiving all correspondence from our team.
Your proposal record will be stored in our system and reviewed as contract opportunities become available. You need not submit your proposal more than once. Should you receive an error message upon submission, please DO NOT resubmit or complete the proposal again. Your data will be saved despite the error, and we will contact you should we need any further information.
Personal Information
International
ESL Services LLC is only authorized to make payments to into accounts
bearing the name of its contractors. Please enter your first and last
name as they appear on your legal identification document(s). (Ex:
Passport, Social Security card, government-issued ID).
Please be aware that we only issue payments either using ACH electronic deposit into American bank accounts, or via PayPal.
* Have
you ever taught with Open English (prior contractor of International ESL
Services, LLC) or participated in our Certification Process?
Educational Consultants provide their weekly availability preferences and are paired with students based on student need,
which is monitored by the company. Consultants provide their weekly
availability preferences and are scheduled for available classes within
those preferences. Open English students tend to demonstrate the most
demand for classes during evening hours (Eastern time). Classes begin on
the hour, every hour. We are unable to offer set schedules each week
and cannot guarantee services to any contractor.
Contractors are scheduled for educational services based on
their availability and the need of the students throughout the day.
Schedules are provided approximately two weeks in advance. At the
current moment, the educational services contractors are scheduled to
provide are:
1) Group classes including welcome period, teaching English for 45 minutes, and completing a feedback form for each student.
2) At times when student attendance
requires less than the scheduled number of contractors, contractors will
use their scheduled time to respond to student questions in the Ask a
Teacher and Writing Feedback queues.
Each educational service opportunity is approximately one hour total. Please list your educational services rate (per one educational service opportunity) in the field below, using US dollars.
Each educational service opportunity is approximately one hour total. Please list your educational services rate (per one educational service opportunity) in the field below, using US dollars.
Consultants
are selected based on business need at the time. Your proposal will be
reviewed in advance of beginning our certification process and you will
be notified if we accept, counter propose or reject your submitted rate
for services. Only submissions which have a pre-approved rate will move
forward in the consulting certification process. Final decisions are
made after the consulting certification process.
* Indicates Response Required
https://www.openenglish.com/en/course/
Live Classes
Our live online classes with
English-speaking teachers are just like being in a real classroom, but
you’ll be learning from the comfort of your home or office. You can
raise your hand to ask a question, make comments, and interact with your
teacher and fellow students.
Classes are grouped according to the
students’ level of comprehension so that teachers can provide more
personalized attention, and so that you’ll be studying with other
students who are at your same level. During class, you can talk about
practical topics and current events in a pleasant and entertaining
atmosphere conducive to practicing your English conversation.
TAKE A VIDEO TOUR OF OPEN ENGLISHExperience the virtual classroom
The Open English program has several advantages:• Classes are available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
• It includes interesting and current subjects in the learning program that will allow you to use every day language in real-life situations.
• With just a small number of students per class teachers can give you students truly personalized attention.
• Open English's cutting edge technology allows students to attend a virtual classroom as they would a real classroom, avoiding the inconveniences of traditional schools.
EXPERIENCE A LIVE CLASS
Native English Teachers
You’ll always have direct access to a native English-speaking teacher – which is incredibly important for your English accent and listening abilities. We carefully select our teachers from a global talent pool for their American accent, energy, skills, and years of experience helping students worldwide reach their goals. They have been trained in proven teaching techniques that accelerate the learning process and are completely committed to helping you reach fluency.
START LEARNING ENGLISH NOW
Beta Client Questionnaire
Shoobx Beta Client Questionnaire |
Powered by SurveyMonkey
Check out our sample surveys and create your own now!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)